"Not pulling his punches, Roger Field's book provides a captivating, yet humorous insight into the journey of a disgruntled soldier disillusioned with 'inept' command. A must-read for all those interested in the honest opinions of former soldiers."

Classic Military Vehicle Magazine

This is a great read due to the style in which it is presented that makes for a book that makes you want to follow the story. Fun and frolics are covered along with death and destruction, and I think everyone who has served or knows someone who has served will see something of the person they know in this story. If you ever meet the author give him a sip of Whisky as it may take him back to another place and a younger person with more of a story to tell.

Read the full review here

Armorama

"Scimitar Into Stanley is a fascinating book which begins by displaying all the frustrations of a staff officer in a rather dysfunctional headquarters, with no proper role and no one listening to him; and it ends with the author in the frontline. Roger field also concedes that the Falklands changed his life; war has an indelible effect on people. Nothing is ever quite the same again."

Colonel W S G Doughty, Guards Magazine, Summer 2022

As featured in

Highlights: 'For those who survived, the conflict was a defining moment in their personal and professional lives. These reflections on the campaigns end are in their own words...'
'Originally destined to spend his time down south manning a radio, the author ended up at the sharp end of fighting… a journey he tells with a mixture of thoughtfulness, humour and irreverence. Field’s later career in the worlds of journalism and publishing is evident throughout in the engrossing style of the narrative.'

Full article available on page 41/42 at:https://edition.pagesuite-professional.co.uk/html5/reader/production/default.aspx?pubname=&edid=e429cf5d-9660-4b55-ab5b-586abb2eb463

Soldier

As reviewed in

Highlight: 'As an honest account of one young officer’s war it is an invaluable addition to the history of that campaign and while some civilian readers may not entirely appreciate the army humour, it is highly recommended.'

Aspects of History

If you want to know how the Falklands War on the ground felt, in its raw intensity, then this is the book for you.

Read the full review here

Phil Curme

As featured in the article: 'Shooting and fishing in the Falklands'

The Field

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

An excellent telling of one officer’s war.
An insightful view, delivered in an honest and calm manner.
Neatly ties together many of the strands from other books with a regimental or battle site focus.
A must read for anyone who has a genuine interest in the events of 1982.

NetGalley, Gordon Campbell

This gripping and frank account of the Falklands War is based on the 12,000 word and contemporaneous diaries of The Field's Roger Field, who saw active duty whilst serving as a captain in The Blues and Royals, attached to HQ 5th Infantry Brigade. It will be welcomed by military folk and civvies with an interest in modern history.

Field is refreshingly open. Prefixing the story with how he felt it was important to speak candidly, he writes with honesty rather than with an axe to grind; his tone is natural, almost conversational, amusing and devoid of literary pretence. Much is relayed in the first person, and interspersed with original diary entries, which gives an immediacy and an excitement to the narrative.

Not that it needs added colour: from his account of cruising down to the South Atlantic aboard the Queen Elizabeth 2, to bonding with journalist Max Hastings, ("the first man into Stanley" thanks to riding pillion on Field's Scimitar) over cigars and Laphroaig while shells rain down around them. This is compelling stuff.

The Field

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

I have just finished reading a delightful and surprisingly insightful text, provided to me in the form of an ARC by its publishers, Pen and Sword, entitled "Scimitar Into Stanley: One Soldier's Falklands War" by Roger Field. The author was a young officer in the British expeditionary force sent to repel the Argentinian invaders in the Falklands
War. The book is based largely on the author's notes, taken during his service in the war. As this genre of literature goes, and largely because of the author's insights into the context of this war and his role in it, examined both contemporaneously through his "diary" and through his long life since then, it is a remarkably candid and well informed look at his experiences and how they fit into a specific time and place as well as what he has made of them since that time. The key here is both the importance of this conflict to the United Kingdom and the sardonic and often enormously amusing point of view of the young officer and the man he has become. I found his elucidation of British military traditions in the deep shadows of a lost empire both funny and often poignant. Further, while the text is no traditional military history of the Falklands campaign, and if that is what you are looking for this is not the place to start, it is, nonetheless, enormously and rather startlingly enlightening in its discussion of one mans experience of a very unique military campaign. Although Field goes to some lengths not to make too much of his own role in this bit of history as theater, it is worth keeping in mind that his role in these events and contribution to the British victory is significant indeed. He was very well placed in events on the ground to chronicle the efforts of the various components of the British military as a kind of inside observer of their struggle, and this, as much as anything else, gives the text its uniquely prescient importance as an historical document. It is a quick read, and one very situated in the late twentieth century, but the author's humanity shines through on every page, and it truly is a delight.

NetGalley, William Harris

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

A well done account of the war in the Falklands. It was interesting to read of the events that occurred. The story was well told and held my attention. A definite must read for those who enjoy this type of story.

NetGalley, Ron Baumer

As an ex armoured recce troop leader with scimitars from the same period I found myself completely concurring with the authors experience regarding the ignorance of how to deploy scimitars shown by many senior infrantry officers. Whilst reading the book I found myself transported back to the army I knew too 40 years ago, in particular the terrific sense of humour and regimental comaraderie. I could almost smell the inside of the turret and even started to remember some of the gunnery drill as Roger described joining the fight at Wireless Ridge.
I never saw action but given that the likely enemy for me was the Russian army I am not unhappy about that - but Roger could not have been clearer in describing the experience of engaging and being engaged in fire by the enemy.
The book not only traces the authors whole war from kitting out to returning home but explains well and amusingly to any reader the day to day expectations and routines he had to follow and the many frustrations of being a junior officer within a brigade HQ, and one who wanted to just use his initiative.
This book is a page turner and should be required reading for any officer who finds himself with armoured cars under his command. It merits a place in the library next to "The reason Why".

William Fergusson