As Tim Voelecker explains in the introduction, this 'anthology of many voices' was intended to bridge the gap between the academic world of naval history and popular naval fiction. Combining, good scholarship with an appealing presentation at an affordable price. The result is, an admirable book that succeeds in all its aims.

The Mariner's Mirror

This is a fascinating account of a key moment in the War of 1812, supported by a range of interesting articles that provide us with the context for both the battle and the men who fought it and comes highly recommended.

History of War

Over the past several years I’ve read numerous accounts of the naval War of 1812 and this particular engagement, but this book is the first to explain how to pronounce “Broke” (said as if spelled “brook”). While most scholarly works include conclusions based on the research conducted, this book provides alternative viewpoints in hopes that readers will draw their own conclusions. Together the essays provide a well-rounded overview, rather than looking at the subject in a bubble, and in doing this, the editor has achieved his four-fold goal.

Pirates & Privateers

While most scholarly works include conclusions based on the research conducted, this book provides alternative viewpoints in hopes that readers will draw their own conclusions. Together the essays provide a well-rounded overview, rather than looking at the subject in a bubble, and in doing this, the editor has achieved his four-fold goal.

Thistles & Pirates

The authors sharp relevance, spite and humour is insightfully reviewed and often beautifully illustrated in either black and white or colour, together making a major contribution to the book's appeal. Davey's skillful assessment is supplemented later in the book by Richard Wilson's consideration of some appropriate contemporary ballads, poetry and music.

The book itself is well-produced, weighty and a pleasure to handle, being printed on good quality paper, facilitating especially the excellent colour illustrations. Altogether, this is an absorbing read, at a remarkably competitive price.

International Journal of Maritime History

An excellent collection of essays on a naval hero of the War of 1812, his ship and a famous engagement. I highly recommend it to readers interested in the naval side of the conflict or maritime warfare in the early 19th century.

The War of 1812 Magazine

Tim Voelcker set out to reverse the neglect shown by historians to one of our finest frigate captains and a man who revolutionised the naval gunnery of this period. With this fine book he has achieved his declared aim.

Naval Historical Collectors and Research Association

This book is well worth reading by all those interested in the age of sail.

Marine News

A welcome addition to the cannon of maritime literature.

International Association of Cape Horners